Back

Suggestions

Make Flight Rising better by sharing your ideas!
TOPIC | Sprit of Arcane
1 2 3
Yeah. That’s right. It’s back with a vengeance. I get why not but it’s not proper grammar since Arcane is like fire or water in the sense it’s used. Sprit of the Arcane doesn’t match up and to be honest I feel it slightly undermines the element. No extreme hate okay? Just understand that Arcane is an element.
Yeah. That’s right. It’s back with a vengeance. I get why not but it’s not proper grammar since Arcane is like fire or water in the sense it’s used. Sprit of the Arcane doesn’t match up and to be honest I feel it slightly undermines the element. No extreme hate okay? Just understand that Arcane is an element.
TBD
What's the suggestion? Or did you post in wrong forum :O
What's the suggestion? Or did you post in wrong forum :O
@chespin
They want the 'the' removed from Spirit of the Arcane

(Which I have no interest in cause it sounds awkward as heck)
@chespin
They want the 'the' removed from Spirit of the Arcane

(Which I have no interest in cause it sounds awkward as heck)
jYPBXj5.png4RsuN8b.pngMXNV32c.pngS7EiNKy.png
@Vendrus Ohh I didn't notice it was even different xD thanks for the clarification!
@Vendrus Ohh I didn't notice it was even different xD thanks for the clarification!
Er, yeah. I mean, "Spirit of the Arcane" sounds better, but NONE of the others have "the", so I think it should be removed
Er, yeah. I mean, "Spirit of the Arcane" sounds better, but NONE of the others have "the", so I think it should be removed
cPW6H3E.png
No support. This is what happens when one of the Flights is an adjective and the rest are nounds–and I don't think consistency is worth the irritatingly poor grammar.
No support. This is what happens when one of the Flights is an adjective and the rest are nounds–and I don't think consistency is worth the irritatingly poor grammar.
windh4.png
@WyvernVenom

yes, normally it is. but in this sense, it is a name of an element. Arcane is a whole flight, like it or not it isn't fair to make ours different on account of infact, wrong grammar. in this sense it becomes a noun under being, again, a name. simple noun rules: Person, Place, Thing, or Animal. Arcane is a thing, like fire, wind or ice. It's like naming a clan a verb or adjective. i mean no offense, but take this matter seriously and will use all of my knowledge of grammar to make this right.

@Vendrus under that simple idea,i think spirit of the ice sounds rather nice. i understand, i really do. and i know this reason is stupid, but it bothers me only my flight has this change. i mean jeez, "Thanks Arcanist" jokes already make me feel ever so slightly undermined...but my familiar standing out isn't fair. We're not the total textbook definition because as the broken record i am, we're a flight, not an adjective in this case.
@WyvernVenom

yes, normally it is. but in this sense, it is a name of an element. Arcane is a whole flight, like it or not it isn't fair to make ours different on account of infact, wrong grammar. in this sense it becomes a noun under being, again, a name. simple noun rules: Person, Place, Thing, or Animal. Arcane is a thing, like fire, wind or ice. It's like naming a clan a verb or adjective. i mean no offense, but take this matter seriously and will use all of my knowledge of grammar to make this right.

@Vendrus under that simple idea,i think spirit of the ice sounds rather nice. i understand, i really do. and i know this reason is stupid, but it bothers me only my flight has this change. i mean jeez, "Thanks Arcanist" jokes already make me feel ever so slightly undermined...but my familiar standing out isn't fair. We're not the total textbook definition because as the broken record i am, we're a flight, not an adjective in this case.
TBD
[quote name="Vendrus" date="2018-05-22 15:21:52" ] (Which I have no interest in cause it sounds awkward as heck) [/quote] I think it sounds awkward as heck the way it is now... "Arcane" in this context is the name of an element, a noun, not an adjective. I will support this all the time because it [i]is[/i] a grammar mistake: grammar is not that rigid. Especially when you're dealing with a fantasy world. "Arcane" here is both a noun and an adjective.
Vendrus wrote on 2018-05-22 15:21:52:
(Which I have no interest in cause it sounds awkward as heck)
I think it sounds awkward as heck the way it is now... "Arcane" in this context is the name of an element, a noun, not an adjective.

I will support this all the time because it is a grammar mistake: grammar is not that rigid. Especially when you're dealing with a fantasy world. "Arcane" here is both a noun and an adjective.
Cheerful Chime Almedha | share project
Fandragons
Lore Starts Here (WIP)
I collect Pulsing Relics!
candle-smol.png ____
47432632.png
Arcane (the flight) is a noun. Arcane (the characteristic) is an adjective. Since the Spirit of (the) Arcane is referring to the Arcane flight, the term should be used as a noun and the familiar name is an actual grammatical error.
Arcane (the flight) is a noun. Arcane (the characteristic) is an adjective. Since the Spirit of (the) Arcane is referring to the Arcane flight, the term should be used as a noun and the familiar name is an actual grammatical error.
wq9PoXA.png
[quote name="BlueJaysFeather" date="2018-05-23 10:24:22" ] Arcane (the flight) is a noun. Arcane (the characteristic) is an adjective. Since the Spirit of (the) Arcane is referring to the Arcane flight, the term should be used as a noun and the familiar name is an actual grammatical error. [/quote] I don't think it is being used as that, tho. I don't think that these as spirits of the flights themselves, but spirits embodying elements. So you can have Spirit of Ice, but for Arcane, Spirit of the Arcane still sounds better.
BlueJaysFeather wrote on 2018-05-23 10:24:22:
Arcane (the flight) is a noun. Arcane (the characteristic) is an adjective. Since the Spirit of (the) Arcane is referring to the Arcane flight, the term should be used as a noun and the familiar name is an actual grammatical error.

I don't think it is being used as that, tho. I don't think that these as spirits of the flights themselves, but spirits embodying elements. So you can have Spirit of Ice, but for Arcane, Spirit of the Arcane still sounds better.
(Please don't ping me in the Suggestions Forum).
1 2 3