Back

General Discussion

Discuss your favorites: TV shows, music, games and hobbies.
TOPIC | Really need some advice!!!!
So my friend's family is moving about four hours away so that her father can do this live-in thing in order to start a new church. Unfortunately, its our senior year.

Now, this in itself wouldn't be too bad if she wasnt so involved in stuff at our school (like marching band, winter guard, and choir). Even then, its not that bad. What makes it so bad, however, is that literally everything worth looking forward to is happening next year: our marching band competes in a state competition, we're traveling to Ohio to compete in Winter Guard Internationals (our director had said that we were the first group in over fifteen years that he would have even considered taking, much less deciding, and guard is also practically her life), she made the highest choir at our school, and a big group of our friends were planning on going to prom together.

We're trying to convince her parents into letting her live at our house for the school year, and my parents adore her so its clear with them. She'll be getting her permit over the summer too, so basically she wouldn't even be a bother to begin with. Her father is even willing to consider this, hear her side out and all, but her mother is acting like a child. She's been guilt-tripping my friend by saying stuff like "you're tearing this family apart!" and "our family stays together" and how she'll need so much help with the younger adopted siblings even though she's been taking care of them for three years now and there's two other older siblings at the house (8th and 10th grade). To make matters worse, she's now avoiding my friend's questions.

I'm really worried about my friend. She's super sweet and caring, but she's awkward and can be a pushover and I know she wouldn't be able to fit in at a new school for only a year. Yeah, she'd make some friends, but its a city school and for the last eight years she's gone to our really good school where bullying is kinda foreign, tbh. Like, none of us can stand each other, but there's only a handful of complete jerks. So I feel like she wouldn't make it very well and she can get depressed when stuff happens and we're not there to pull her back up because she just shoulders it all.

Is this a familiar situation to anybody? We need some advice on how to convince her parents, and if anyone can share some situations and pros and cons that would be great.

tl;dr: my friend's family is moving during the worst possible time, and we need some advice to convince her parents to let her stay with me.
So my friend's family is moving about four hours away so that her father can do this live-in thing in order to start a new church. Unfortunately, its our senior year.

Now, this in itself wouldn't be too bad if she wasnt so involved in stuff at our school (like marching band, winter guard, and choir). Even then, its not that bad. What makes it so bad, however, is that literally everything worth looking forward to is happening next year: our marching band competes in a state competition, we're traveling to Ohio to compete in Winter Guard Internationals (our director had said that we were the first group in over fifteen years that he would have even considered taking, much less deciding, and guard is also practically her life), she made the highest choir at our school, and a big group of our friends were planning on going to prom together.

We're trying to convince her parents into letting her live at our house for the school year, and my parents adore her so its clear with them. She'll be getting her permit over the summer too, so basically she wouldn't even be a bother to begin with. Her father is even willing to consider this, hear her side out and all, but her mother is acting like a child. She's been guilt-tripping my friend by saying stuff like "you're tearing this family apart!" and "our family stays together" and how she'll need so much help with the younger adopted siblings even though she's been taking care of them for three years now and there's two other older siblings at the house (8th and 10th grade). To make matters worse, she's now avoiding my friend's questions.

I'm really worried about my friend. She's super sweet and caring, but she's awkward and can be a pushover and I know she wouldn't be able to fit in at a new school for only a year. Yeah, she'd make some friends, but its a city school and for the last eight years she's gone to our really good school where bullying is kinda foreign, tbh. Like, none of us can stand each other, but there's only a handful of complete jerks. So I feel like she wouldn't make it very well and she can get depressed when stuff happens and we're not there to pull her back up because she just shoulders it all.

Is this a familiar situation to anybody? We need some advice on how to convince her parents, and if anyone can share some situations and pros and cons that would be great.

tl;dr: my friend's family is moving during the worst possible time, and we need some advice to convince her parents to let her stay with me.
tumblr_na5dh68Ezc1tfzajgo2_500.gif
Have you tried getting your parents or her dad to explain why it's a good idea to her mom? She might be more open to the idea. You could also try to set up a schedule (like she could stay at your house weekdays to go to school and be at her parents house during the weekend.) It also might help to explain to her mom that it's for school, since she seems to be taking it personally. I hope it works out for you!
Have you tried getting your parents or her dad to explain why it's a good idea to her mom? She might be more open to the idea. You could also try to set up a schedule (like she could stay at your house weekdays to go to school and be at her parents house during the weekend.) It also might help to explain to her mom that it's for school, since she seems to be taking it personally. I hope it works out for you!
568.png
@octopusbear
thank you for your advice! It'll definitely go into consideration.
@octopusbear
thank you for your advice! It'll definitely go into consideration.
tumblr_na5dh68Ezc1tfzajgo2_500.gif
I honestly think we should just get the guard involved. She's got so much support dude.
And obviously we know she won't be able to stand up to her parents, you know that, so maybe we should come up with some sort of argument/speech etc and practice it with her during B-lunch in a practice room?

But yeah, for all you uninvolved peeps on FR, some help would be amazing. And for our friend who'll probably look at this thread eventually, talk to us!
-G
I honestly think we should just get the guard involved. She's got so much support dude.
And obviously we know she won't be able to stand up to her parents, you know that, so maybe we should come up with some sort of argument/speech etc and practice it with her during B-lunch in a practice room?

But yeah, for all you uninvolved peeps on FR, some help would be amazing. And for our friend who'll probably look at this thread eventually, talk to us!
-G
2niy60w.jpg
@HauntedHairbrush
I'm gonna make a guess and suggest that the friend's mom might feel like she's being abandoned. Moms do that sometimes XD where they act like it's all your fault but really they are upset and worried about things they're afraid to admit. (Because yes, it's kinda selfish if she misses her kid and wants her to stay, but also understandable cos she's her mom)

If the mom could see that finishing up senior year at the current school really is the best thing for her kid's happiness, that would be a hard case to contest. It might be easier for the friend to offer some sort of compromise so her mom wouldn't have to worry as much (regular phone calls to keep in touch maybe?)

It sounds like less of a logical thing and more of an issue of the mom being afraid of losing her kid. Recognizing that fear might help discussions go better.
@HauntedHairbrush
I'm gonna make a guess and suggest that the friend's mom might feel like she's being abandoned. Moms do that sometimes XD where they act like it's all your fault but really they are upset and worried about things they're afraid to admit. (Because yes, it's kinda selfish if she misses her kid and wants her to stay, but also understandable cos she's her mom)

If the mom could see that finishing up senior year at the current school really is the best thing for her kid's happiness, that would be a hard case to contest. It might be easier for the friend to offer some sort of compromise so her mom wouldn't have to worry as much (regular phone calls to keep in touch maybe?)

It sounds like less of a logical thing and more of an issue of the mom being afraid of losing her kid. Recognizing that fear might help discussions go better.
c40lCDG.pngLs34PWv.png7dZl5Un.png
@RGecko
Thank you so much!! That would really make things go smoother!
@RGecko
Thank you so much!! That would really make things go smoother!
tumblr_na5dh68Ezc1tfzajgo2_500.gif
@BellowsLizard
Bro, the guard already is involved. Sorta. Mainly thinking of ways for her to be disowned but still, it's the thought that counts.
@BellowsLizard
Bro, the guard already is involved. Sorta. Mainly thinking of ways for her to be disowned but still, it's the thought that counts.
tumblr_na5dh68Ezc1tfzajgo2_500.gif