I need to know which is more inaccurate the hobbit/ The lord of the rings or
Percy Jackson/ Heroes of Olympus compared to their movie adaptations.
Percy Jackson/ Heroes of Olympus compared to their movie adaptations.
General Discussion
Discuss your favorites: TV shows, music, games and hobbies.
TOPIC | Which is more inaccurate
I need to know which is more inaccurate the hobbit/ The lord of the rings or
Percy Jackson/ Heroes of Olympus compared to their movie adaptations.
Percy Jackson/ Heroes of Olympus compared to their movie adaptations.
what do you mean by inaccurate tho?
inaccurate about what?
inaccurate about what?
what do you mean by inaccurate tho?
inaccurate about what?
inaccurate about what?
|
Hiro   | Brazil | FR +4 Sornieth's #2 Seeker Orb connoisseur & collector -> please ping me! |
|
|
i'm confused what the question is? are you asking if they are inaccurate to mythology that they're based on?
lotr isn't really based on any particular mythology, tolkien pulled a lot of inspiration from different facets but it isn't meant to be based on anything compared to something like the percy jackson books.
lotr isn't really based on any particular mythology, tolkien pulled a lot of inspiration from different facets but it isn't meant to be based on anything compared to something like the percy jackson books.
i'm confused what the question is? are you asking if they are inaccurate to mythology that they're based on?
lotr isn't really based on any particular mythology, tolkien pulled a lot of inspiration from different facets but it isn't meant to be based on anything compared to something like the percy jackson books.
lotr isn't really based on any particular mythology, tolkien pulled a lot of inspiration from different facets but it isn't meant to be based on anything compared to something like the percy jackson books.
i think the Hobbit movies are kind of inaccurate but Percy Jackson... oofffff no never watch it... EDIT more details:
So I read lotr and watched the movies, same for the Hobbit. I'd say lotr is the best movie adaption I've seen, and the Hobbit ones weren't as good but wasn't as bad as Percy Jackson.
For Percy Jackson movies, I recently watched a few clips and just.... Instant facepalm.... Who could make such a horrible movie?! Even if it wasn't adapted from anything it still isn't the best. Like in the one scene, it shows that Percy has the flying shoes instead of Grover, which is a major part of the story, and also in this fight scene he is controlling all the water in a water tower when he doesn't do anything like that in the book.
Overall, the Percy Jackson movies are waaaaay worse than The Hobbit or LOTR.
Plus here's a picture of HORRIBLE movie adaptions:
https://ibb.co/N68xXzp
So I read lotr and watched the movies, same for the Hobbit. I'd say lotr is the best movie adaption I've seen, and the Hobbit ones weren't as good but wasn't as bad as Percy Jackson.
For Percy Jackson movies, I recently watched a few clips and just.... Instant facepalm.... Who could make such a horrible movie?! Even if it wasn't adapted from anything it still isn't the best. Like in the one scene, it shows that Percy has the flying shoes instead of Grover, which is a major part of the story, and also in this fight scene he is controlling all the water in a water tower when he doesn't do anything like that in the book.
Overall, the Percy Jackson movies are waaaaay worse than The Hobbit or LOTR.
Plus here's a picture of HORRIBLE movie adaptions:
https://ibb.co/N68xXzp
i think the Hobbit movies are kind of inaccurate but Percy Jackson... oofffff no never watch it... EDIT more details:
So I read lotr and watched the movies, same for the Hobbit. I'd say lotr is the best movie adaption I've seen, and the Hobbit ones weren't as good but wasn't as bad as Percy Jackson.
For Percy Jackson movies, I recently watched a few clips and just.... Instant facepalm.... Who could make such a horrible movie?! Even if it wasn't adapted from anything it still isn't the best. Like in the one scene, it shows that Percy has the flying shoes instead of Grover, which is a major part of the story, and also in this fight scene he is controlling all the water in a water tower when he doesn't do anything like that in the book.
Overall, the Percy Jackson movies are waaaaay worse than The Hobbit or LOTR.
Plus here's a picture of HORRIBLE movie adaptions:
https://ibb.co/N68xXzp
So I read lotr and watched the movies, same for the Hobbit. I'd say lotr is the best movie adaption I've seen, and the Hobbit ones weren't as good but wasn't as bad as Percy Jackson.
For Percy Jackson movies, I recently watched a few clips and just.... Instant facepalm.... Who could make such a horrible movie?! Even if it wasn't adapted from anything it still isn't the best. Like in the one scene, it shows that Percy has the flying shoes instead of Grover, which is a major part of the story, and also in this fight scene he is controlling all the water in a water tower when he doesn't do anything like that in the book.
Overall, the Percy Jackson movies are waaaaay worse than The Hobbit or LOTR.
Plus here's a picture of HORRIBLE movie adaptions:
https://ibb.co/N68xXzp
movies-to-books inaccuracy? despite having never actually watched LotR, i can guarantee you the percy jackson movies are less accurate.
i think the writers read, like, four chapters of the book and just made the rest up themselves
i think the writers read, like, four chapters of the book and just made the rest up themselves
movies-to-books inaccuracy? despite having never actually watched LotR, i can guarantee you the percy jackson movies are less accurate.
i think the writers read, like, four chapters of the book and just made the rest up themselves
i think the writers read, like, four chapters of the book and just made the rest up themselves
@MagicMistle
that the Percy Jackson BOOKS the movies are the worst thing to exist like I have never seen a worse adaptation EVER I SWEAR.
plz dont watch them.
that the Percy Jackson BOOKS the movies are the worst thing to exist like I have never seen a worse adaptation EVER I SWEAR.
plz dont watch them.
@MagicMistle
that the Percy Jackson BOOKS the movies are the worst thing to exist like I have never seen a worse adaptation EVER I SWEAR.
plz dont watch them.
that the Percy Jackson BOOKS the movies are the worst thing to exist like I have never seen a worse adaptation EVER I SWEAR.
plz dont watch them.
[font=monospace][b]I think I kinda understand what the OP is trying to say.
For me? I think the Percy Jackson books had the most horribly inaccurate movie adaptations. They didn't even add in that war of god dude that Percy had an epic fight with near the end of the first book. Really disappointing, man. [emoji=guardian sad size=1]
I think I kinda understand what the OP is trying to say.
For me? I think the Percy Jackson books had the most horribly inaccurate movie adaptations. They didn't even add in that war of god dude that Percy had an epic fight with near the end of the first book. Really disappointing, man.
For me? I think the Percy Jackson books had the most horribly inaccurate movie adaptations. They didn't even add in that war of god dude that Percy had an epic fight with near the end of the first book. Really disappointing, man.
[quote name="@MagicMistle" date="2019-09-28 22:59:35" ]
@/ohwowimcool
I am fairly sure that it is norse
[/quote]
tolkien was a middle/old english professor who was inspired by old/mid eng folklore and legends
anyway, i haven't seen lotr but i can def vouch for percy jackson being a wildly awful adaptation
@MagicMistle wrote on 2019-09-28 22:59:35:
@/ohwowimcool
I am fairly sure that it is norse
I am fairly sure that it is norse
tolkien was a middle/old english professor who was inspired by old/mid eng folklore and legends
anyway, i haven't seen lotr but i can def vouch for percy jackson being a wildly awful adaptation
Ollie | he/him
