i love the first three you mentioned to DEATH! old gods is my top fave tho.
i made it through s1 of the white vault but then i binged a few other things - i really need to go back and relisten before catching up!
and oh YES death in the afternoon! i loooove caitlin she is honestly my idol. if i could id be at the highest tier for her patreon, but i guess ill settle for enough $ to see her secret vlogs
she also narrates her audiobooks (at least will my cat eat my eyeballs)
i listen to lots of crime and paranormal podcasts besides those. if you like those subjects, i enjoy and thats why we drink (paranormal/crime combo), crime show, let's not meet, something was wrong, and crime junkie. theres a few others but those are my top recommendations!
as for others, i REALLY enjoy snap judgement. each episode is someone telling their unique story. they also have spooked, which is their paranormal/seasonal spinoff podcast that i cannot recommend enough. some of those stories stuck with me in a good way.
i also like the adventure zone (dnd), sawbones (medical history), the black tapes (horror fiction), archive 81 (???? fiction), and bad vibes (horror fiction). just started the silt verses, seems spooky! we seem to have very similar taste so i can throw my entire "to-listen" list at you if you want haha
going to add mistholme museum to my list, ty!